Now that you mention it, I got some too. Then I found out that it was conditioner residue and not shampoo bar residue, because I quit shampoo and the stuff is still coming out.

If it's soap residue, you might want to follow each hairwash with an ACV rinse if you don't already do so. During my shampoo bar month, I did bar, ACV, then Suave C, heavy C.

HTH
Anais

Thanks!  I was hoping you two would check in on this topic 
I will try clarifying with baking soda and see if that helps clear things up -- my hair just feels dirty near the scalp, but doesn't look it, on the up side I can do updo's with only one hairstick because it isn't so slippery

The clarifying worked for a short while.  But my hair started to leave white gunk on my combs again and was feeling icky again even after it was just washed.  The only product I used on my hair beside the shampoo bar is jojoba oil, and that has been sporadic since starting the shampoo bar.  So I really think it is the shampoo bar residue on my combs. It was also much harder to de-tangle all the time. 
Last night I decided my experiment with shampoo bars was done.  I did another baking soda clarify then did a C-COW-C.  It feels soooooo much better. 
I wanted to settle the question of the shampoo bar before going on a long trip.  I was hoping the bar would work--makes packing much easier, but I just couldn't stand my hair like that for another month!  I felt I was constantly fighting to keep the icks down to a tolerable level.